Current Coles County Judges

Hon. Mitchell K. Shick, Circuit Judge
Hon. Brien J. O’Brien, Circuit Judge
Hon. Mark E. Bovard, Circuit Judge
Hon. Brian L. Bower, Circuit Judge
Hon. Christopher L. Wetzel, Associate Judge

History of Judges of the Fifth Judicial Circuit of Illinois

Term Name City / Notes
At Large Circuit Court Judges
1897–1996: three positions  |  1996–Present: four positions
1897-1902Ferdinand BookwalterDanville
1897-1903Henry Van SellarParis
1897-1903Frank K. DunnCharleston
1902-1915Morton W. ThompsonDanville
1903-1909James W. CraigMattoon
1903-1915E. R. E. KimbroughDanville
1909-1915William B. ScholfieldMarshall
1915-1927Augustus A. PartlowDanville
1915-1927Walter BrewerToledo
1915-1927John H. MarshallCharleston
1927-1933S. Murray ClarkDanville
1927-1933Charles A. ShueyCharleston
1927-1951George W. BristowParis
1933-1935Craig Van MeterMattoon
1933-1949Casper S. PlattDanville
1936-1939Grendel F. BennettMarshall
1939-1957Ben F. AndersonCharleston
1951-1963John F. SpiveyDanville
1951-1963Robert F. CottonParis
1957-1963Harry I. HannahMattoon
Spivey Judgeship
1964-1971John F. SpiveyDanville
1971-1979Frank J. MeyerDanville
1980-1985John P. MeyerDanville
1986Matthew A. JurczakDanville
1986-1996Rita B. GarmanDanville
1997-2016Claudia S. AndersonDanville
2017-Charles C. HallDanville
Cotton Judgeship
1964-1971Robert F. CottonParis
1972-1998Ralph S. PearmanParis
1998-2022James R. GlennMattoon
2022-Brian L. BowerCharleston
Hannah Judgeship
1964-1973Harry I. HannahMattoon
1973-1980Thomas M. BurkeCharleston
1980-2001Paul C. KomadaCharleston
2001-Mitchell K. ShickCharleston
Cini Judgeship
1996-2008Dale A. CiniMattoon
2008-2010Richard E. ScottParis
2010-Matthew L. SullivanParis
Clark County Judges
Judges of Probate
1821-1823Samuel Prevo
1823-1825Charles Neeley
1825-1835Jacob Harlan
1835-1837Uri Manley
Probate Justices of the Peace
1837-1843Uri Manley
1843-1849Stephen Archer
County Judges
1849-1853Stephen Archer
1853-1854John Bartlett
1854-1857John Stockwell
1857-1869William C. Whitlock
1869-1873William R. Griffith
1873-1877Justin Harlan
1877-1882William R. Griffith
1882-1886Ethan A. Sutton
1886-1894Henry Gasaway
1894-1898William T. Hollenbeck
1898-1902J. C. Perdue
1902-1906Everett Connelly
1906-1914Hershel R. Snavely
1914-1918A. L. Ruffner
1918-1922Edward Pearce
1922-1926Harry M. Janney
1926-1932Jed Gard
1934-1938C. A. Williams
1938-1946Theodore Thompson
1946-1958John M. Hollenbeck
1958-1963Zollie O. Arbogast
Associate Judges
1964-1967Zollie O. Arbogast
1968-1971Caslon K. Bennett
Resident Circuit Court Judges
1971-1988Caslon K. Bennett
1988-1989Zollie O. Arbogast
1990James K. Robinson
1990-Tracy W. Resch
Coles County Judges
Judges of Probate
1831-1834James P. Jones
1834John F. Smyth
1834-1835S. M. Dunbar
1835-1837William Collom
Probate Justices of the Peace
1837-1841Reuben Canterbury
1841-1843John W. Trower
1843-1847Robert S. Mills
1847-1849William W. Bishop
County Judges
1849-1857William W. Bishop
1857-1864Gideon Edwards
1864-1865Joshua P. Cooper
1865-1869McHenry Brooks
1869-1873Abner M. Peterson
1873-1877William E. Adams
1877-1882James R. Cunningham
1882-1886Charles Bennett
1886-1894Lapsley C. Henley
1894-1898Sumner S. Anderson
1898-1902John P. Harrah
1902-1910T. N. Cofer
1910-1922John P. Harrah
1922-1930J. B. Lane
1930-1950John T. Kincaid
1950-1963William J. Sunderman
Associate Judges
1964-1971William J. Sunderman
Resident Circuit Court Judges
1971-1989William J. Sunderman
1989-2003Ashton C. Waller
2004-2017Teresa K. Righter
2018-Mark E. Bovard
City Judges – Mattoon
1898-1902James F. HughesMattoon
1902-1906Lapsley C. HenleyMattoon
1906-1907Horace S. ClarkMattoon
1909-1910George D. WilsonMattoon
1910-1922John C. McNuttMattoon
1922-1925Isaac B. CraigMattoon
1925-1936Clarence H. DouglasMattoon
1936-1963Jacob BerkowitzMattoon
Associate Judges (Mattoon)
1964-1971Jacob BerkowitzMattoon
Resident Circuit Court Judges (Mattoon)
1971-1976Jacob BerkowitzMattoon
1977-1991Joseph R. SpitzMattoon
1992-2011Gary W. JacobsMattoon
2012-Brien J. O’BrienMattoon
City Judges – Charleston
1910-1914Charles A. ShueyCharleston
1914-1918Charles A. QuackenbushCharleston
1918-1922John T. KincaidCharleston
1922-1930Ben F. AndersonCharleston
1930-1936Herbert S. AndersonCharleston
1936-1960C. Wade BarrickCharleston
1960-1962Jack H. AndersonCharleston
Cumberland County Judges
Probate Justices of the Peace
1843Elisha H. Starkweather
1843-1849James M. Ward
County Judges
1849-1853James M. Ward
1853-1861William E. Smith
1861-1864Hiram B. Decius
1864-1869Reuben Bloomfield
1869-1873Wiley Ross
1873-1882John W. Miller
1882-1886Leonidas L. Logan
1886-1890Phillip Welshimer
1890-1894Leonidas L. Logan
1894-1898Gershom Monohon
1898-1902Elias M. McPherson
1902-1906Stephen B. Rariden
1906-1910A. L. Ruffner
1910-1917Stephen B. Rariden
1917-1918Millard C. Everhart
1918-1930Albert F. Bussard
1930-1942Charles M. Connor
1942-1954Millard C. Everhart
1954-1963William J. Hill
Associate Judges
1964-1966William J. Hill
1966-1971James R. Watson
Resident Circuit Court Judges
1971-1989James R. Watson
1990Thomas M. Burke
1990-2002Robert B. Cochonour
2002-2016Millard S. Everhart
2016-Jonathan T. Braden
Edgar County Judges
Judges of Probate
1823-1826Lewis Murphy
1826-1827William Lowry
1827-1828Smith Shaw
1828-1837Jonathan Mayo
Probate Justices of the Peace
1837-1839Henry Neville
1839-1849Samuel Connelly
County Judges
1849-1853Samuel Connelly
1853-1857James Steele
1857-1861A. B. Austin
1861-1865George K. Larkin
1865-1869Andrew Y. Trogdon
1869-1877Robert B. Lamon
1877-1886Andrew Y. Trogdon
1886-1894Andrew J. Hunter
1894Henry Tanner
1894-1898Erasmus G. Rose
1898-1902Stephen I. Headley
1902-1910Walter S. Lamon
1910-1922Daniel V. Dayton
1922-1946Paul B. Lauher
1946-1963Howard T. Ruff
Associate Judges
1964-1971Howard T. Ruff
Resident Circuit Court Judges
1971-1972Howard T. Ruff
1972-1986Carl A. Lund
1986-2000Richard E. Scott
2000-2006H. Dean Andrews
2006-2022Steven L. Garst
2022-Mark R. Isaf
Vermilion County Judges
Judges of Probate
1826-1837Amos Williams
Probate Justices of the Peace
1837-1849Norman D. Palmer
County Judges
1849-1857Guy Merrill
1857-1858Norman D. Palmer
1858-1863Joseph Peters
1863-1865Robert B. Lamon
1865-1868Daniel Clapp
1868-1882Raymond W. Hanford
1882-1890David D. Evans
1890-1897John G. Thompson
1897-1902Morton W. Thompson
1902-1905S. Murray Clark
1905-1906Fred Draper
1906-1909Isaac A. Love
1909-1918Lawrence T. Allen
1918-1925Thomas A. Graham
1925-1930William T. Henderson
1930-1950Harlin M. Steely
1950-1962Frank J. Meyer
1962-1963James K. Robinson
Associate Judges
1964-1971James K. Robinson
Resident Circuit Court Judges
1971-1987James K. Robinson
1987-1988Jerry A. Davis
1988-2006Thomas J. Fahey
2006-2022Nancy S. Fahey
2023-2024Robert E. McIntire
2024-Mark S. Goodwin
Probate Judges
1910-1914Clinton Abernathy
1914-1930Walter J. Bookwalter
1930-1938Ralph M. Jinkins
1938-1954Arthur R. Hall
1954-1958John W. Unger
1958-1963Paul M. Wright
Associate Judges (Probate Seat)
1964-1971Paul M. Wright
Resident Circuit Court Judges (Probate Seat)
1971-1987Paul M. Wright
1987-2000John P. O’Rourke
2000-Craig H. DeArmond
Clary Judgeship – Resident Circuit Court Judges
1998-2013Michael D. Clary
2014-Thomas M. O’Shaughnessy
Associate Circuit Court Judges
Clark, Edgar, and Cumberland Counties – Magistrates
1965-1971Henri I. Ripstra
Clark, Edgar, and Cumberland Counties – Associate Circuit Court Judges
1971Henri I. Ripstra
1972-1986Richard E. Scott
1987-2000H. Dean Andrews
2001-David W. Lewis
Coles County – Magistrates
1965-1966Mark B. Hunt
1966-1971Thomas M. Burke
Coles County – Associate Circuit Court Judges
1971-1973Thomas M. Burke
1974-1980Tom E. Grace
1980-1983Loren J. Kabbes
1983-1989Ashton C. Waller
1989-1992Gary W. Jacobs
1993-1996Dale A. Cini
1997-2004Teresa K. Righter
2005-2012Brien J. O’Brien
2012-2018Mark E. Bovard
2019-2022Brian L. Bower
2023-Christopher L. Wetzel
Vermilion County
1965–1967: two positions  |  1967–2020: three positions  |  2020–Present: four positions
Vermilion County – Magistrates
1965-1971John F. Twomey
1965-1971Matthew A. Jurczak
1967-1971Lawrence T. Allen, Jr.
Vermilion County – Associate Circuit Court Judges
1971-1973John F. Twomey
1971-1984Matthew A. Jurczak
1971-1984Lawrence T. Allen, Jr.
1974-1986Rita B. Garman
1984-1991Joseph C. Moore
1984-2010Joseph P. Skowronski
1987-1995David G. Bernthal
1991-2009James K. Borbely
1995-2010Gordon R. Stipp
1995-1997Joseph C. Moore
2009-2024Mark S. Goodwin
2010-2024Derek J. Girton
2010-Karen E. Wall
2020-Charles D. Mockbee IV
2024-Nicolas J. Boileau
2024-2025Robert E. McIntire
2025-Lindsay J. Starwalt
Chief Judges
1964-1966Robert F. Cotton
1966-1968John F. Spivey
1968-1972Harry I. Hannah
1972-1976Jacob Berkowitz
1976-1995Ralph S. Pearman
1995-2000Richard E. Scott
2000-2001James R. Glenn
2001-2003Ashton C. Waller
2003-2007James R. Glenn
2007-2011Tracy W. Resch
2011-2015Millard S. Everhart
2015-2017Craig H. DeArmond
2017-2021Mitchell K. Shick
2021-2025Thomas M. O’Shaughnessy
2025-Mark E. Bovard
Administrative Assistants
Secretaries
1964-1966Mildred P. Weston
1966-1967Mildred J. Towle
Administrative Secretaries
1967-1968Mildred J. Towle
1968-1985Sibyl E. Etchason
Administrative Assistants
1985-1991Sibyl E. Etchason
1991-2007Ann E. Staats
2007-2013Kathleen A. Lay
2013-2016Rustye D. Cooley
2016-2019Alexander Wakeland
2019-Lori J. Pearson